Second Build Selection

[crosscut]

With the help of this forum, my first build, a flat bottom skiff, came out really nice. I hope you can be a help in selecting my second build. In my head, I feel that the next logical step would be a multi-chine build like a Nutshell Pram. In my heart, I really want to build a Penobscot 14. I've seen the P14 described as a good started project, but, it looks intimidating to me. Here is where I need advise. Should I go with my head or heart? Is there a good compromise boat out there like a smaller lapstrake boat? Thanks

[marshmat]

Hi crosscut,

I think this is the one?
http://www.archdavisdesigns.com/davis_penobscot14.html

OK, so it may look a bit intimidating. But:
- You've already built one boat and it sounds you were quite happy with how it turned out
- You really like the P14 (and not surprising, it's an awfully pretty boat)
- If I read the Arch Davis site correctly, they include full-size patterns and a detailed 74pg build manual along with the set of 12 drawings

If this is what you want to build, why spend your time and money on a "compromise boat" that isn't really what you're looking for? Treat the PB14 as a challenge and recognize that you'll encounter some problems, you'll work through them, and you'll come out of it a happier owner and a more experienced boatbuilder.

[elmog]

Crosscut-

Can you post a pic of your completed flat bottomed skiff? Jim

[crosscut]

Jim: I was reluctant to post a picture on the forum, my work pales in comparison to what I have seen here. I guess It is only fair to post a picture since I got so much help here.
http://i223.photobucket.com/albums/dd259/Seapro190/BoatProject048.jpg

[Rick Willoughby]

The only part of the photo that looks a bit daggy is the rust on the trailer.

It looks a nicely built and finished craft. I hope it rewards the obvious effort put into it.

If only I had the patience for such workmanship.

Will be interested in what you take on next.

Rick W

[lazeyjack]

nice Fair job me lad,

[crosscut]

Ah........ the trailer. That was rescue mission. The trailer set in the weeds for 8 years before I got hold of it. I rebuilt the hubs with bearings, seals and races, replaced the lights and replaced some shackles. I sold the boat on Tuesday. A gentleman fell in love with it. He said if reminded him so much of the boat he and his father had when he was a kid. He has boated all his life and knows wooden boats need TLC. I sold it to him for what I had in it for materials. A real win, win, he is really happy and I can do build number two.

[BHOFM]

I don't see anything but a beautiful job, and if you factor
in it was your first, it is top of the line!

I like your choice of color for your shed and house!!

This was taken about 3 hours after the tornado hit! I let the
yard go to seed every spring! A 15 year old girl died just
a few blocks from us on the morning this happened! We
were very lucky, just minor damage!!

Again, job well done!

[elmog]

Thanks Crosscut for posting the picture. A real fine job you've done. I'll bet you get as much fun out of building as you do floating! It shows in your workmanship. Jim

[PAR]

Nothing to be ashamed of in that photo Crosscut.

The Penobscot 14 is a fine little boat. I prefer the sloop rig over the other options, but I'm not sure I like the batten lap method, though I can see how a novice lap builder could benefit from it.

http://www.phys.uwosh.edu/rioux/boats/scot/scot_56.jpg

There are lots of designs in this size (thousands). Take your time, look at lots of designs and if you do half as nice a job on your second as your little skiff, it'll be something anyone would be proud to own.

[Lt. Holden]

Crosscut, no apologies are necessary! That is a fine looking boat and the craftmanship and pride you put into it shine. Great job and good luck with your next build.

[crosscut]

Thanks for the encouragement. I think I might skip the Nutshell and move on to the Penobscot. I will order the study plans and video to see if I can follow everything.

[PAR]

I posted an unfinished Penobscot picture above. It will be a more challenging build then your skiff, but a rewarding result I'm sure.